CLEVELAND, OH – The first week of the 2025 NFL preseason has concluded, offering fans and franchises a tantalizing first glimpse of this year's rookie class. While coaches emphasize that these games are primarily for evaluation, the performances of several high-profile newcomers have already begun to shape narratives. Among the most discussed are Cleveland Browns quarterback Shedeur Sanders and Indianapolis Colts tight end Tyler Warren, both of whom delivered performances that not only met but, in some cases, exceeded lofty expectations.

According to post-game analysis from NFL.com's Chad Reuter, who graded notable rookie outings from each contest, Sanders and Warren were definitive standouts, signaling their readiness to contribute early in their professional careers.

Sanders Seizes Opportunity with Poise

All eyes were on Shedeur Sanders as he took the field for the Cleveland Browns. The highly decorated college quarterback, selected to bring long-term stability to the position, was given significant playing time in the second half of the Browns' matchup against the Green Bay Packers. He responded with a display of poise and precision that electrified the home crowd.

Sanders finished his debut completing 14 of 18 passes for 165 yards and two touchdowns, leading the Browns on two consecutive scoring drives. His first touchdown was a perfectly placed 22-yard throw to the corner of the end zone, while his second came on a quick read and decisive throw over the middle on a third-down play. Analysts noted his calm demeanor in the pocket and his ability to progress through his reads—traits not always evident in a rookie's first taste of NFL-level speed.

Reuter's grades from NFL.com highlighted Sanders's command of the offense, noting he "took advantage of a huge opportunity" and appeared comfortable running the two-minute drill. While the performance came against second- and third-string defenders, his accuracy and decision-making have given the Browns' coaching staff and fanbase a significant dose of optimism for his development trajectory.

Warren Appears Worthy of Immense Hype

In Indianapolis, the buzz surrounding tight end Tyler Warren has been palpable since he was drafted. Known for his rare combination of size, speed, and reliable hands, Warren entered his first preseason game with immense pressure to perform. He delivered emphatically in the Colts' game against the Chicago Bears.

Warren was a primary target from the outset, finishing the game with five receptions for 78 yards and a spectacular touchdown. The scoring play saw him out-muscle a linebacker to secure a contested catch in the end zone, demonstrating the physical dominance that made him a top prospect. Beyond his receiving prowess, coaches were reportedly pleased with his contributions in the running game, where his blocking helped spring several positive gains.

The immediate chemistry with the Colts' quarterbacks was evident, and his performance has quickly positioned him as a potential key weapon in the team's offensive scheme for the upcoming season. NFL.com's Reuter concluded that Warren "appears worthy of his immense hype," a sentiment echoed by Colts beat reporters who observed his consistent playmaking ability throughout training camp.

The Importance of a Strong Start

While preseason results must be viewed with caution, strong debuts are crucial for rookies. They serve as a validation of draft-day decisions and, more importantly, help players build confidence and earn the trust of their coaches and veteran teammates. For players like Sanders and Warren, who carry the weight of high expectations, passing this first test is a critical step.

As teams prepare for Week 2 of the preseason, the performances from Week 1 have set the stage. Rookies across the league will continue to battle for roster spots and playing time, but for at least one week, Shedeur Sanders and Tyler Warren have shown they not only belong but have the potential to become impact players in the National Football League.